I'm just going with the justification that they were drunk, Roy is stubborn, and no one was good at switching gears once Roy decided they were all Hufflepuffs. (The Sorting Hat has spoken!)
(I'm sure there was more of a rationalization in the middle that drunk-me had, but sober-me does not remember what it was.)
General thought process: Ted is obviously a Hufflepuff >>> everyone else was Slytherin material before meeting Ted but his niceness rubbed off on them so now they are Hufflepuffs too >>> but wait, Ted is an American version of Arthur Weasley which means he's actually Gryffindor >>> several more rounds of alcohol >>> 100 points to Hufflepuff!
me either
I'm just going with the justification that they were drunk, Roy is stubborn, and no one was good at switching gears once Roy decided they were all Hufflepuffs. (The Sorting Hat has spoken!)
(I'm sure there was more of a rationalization in the middle that drunk-me had, but sober-me does not remember what it was.)
General thought process: Ted is obviously a Hufflepuff >>> everyone else was Slytherin material before meeting Ted but his niceness rubbed off on them so now they are Hufflepuffs too >>> but wait, Ted is an American version of Arthur Weasley which means he's actually Gryffindor >>> several more rounds of alcohol >>> 100 points to Hufflepuff!